10 Best Waterproof Eye Makeup Removers of 2019

While applying makeup we are usually so excited about looking our best that we don’t put much thought in to how we will remove it later or what products we will use for the job.

Using a quality waterproof eye makeup remover should be an important step in your skin care routine because the skin around the eyes is super delicate and you wouldn’t want to use any product that will cause irritation or skin damage.

Waterproof eye makeup removers should not only help you remove your makeup effortlessly but also offer some skincare benefits. But how do you pick the best one out of the many options available?

To help you in your search we have compiled a list of the best waterproof eye makeup removers that are popular among beauty enthusiasts and trusted by many.

So whether you have just your favorite waterproof mascara on or you have adorned your eyes with every waterproof eye makeup there is out there, these products will gently erase all traces of makeup in seconds while leaving the skin around your eyes feeling clean and refreshed.

Best Waterproof Eye Makeup Removers Reviewed

1. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes

Specs:

  • Ophthalmologist and Dermatologist Tested
  • Allergy Tested
  • Alcohol and Fragrance Free

The pack contains ultra soft cloths soaked in cleansing solution that you can use to wipe of waterproof makeup with ease. It effectively removes all makeup and leaves no residue behind, eliminating the need to wash your skin after. The formula is gentle and safe even for contact lens wearers so you can confidently wear your makeup and look forward to removing it in one easy step.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Reseal-able pack.
  • Wipes off makeup gently, even waterproof mascara.
  • Safe for sensitive skin and contact lens wearers.
  • Hydrates the skin with aloe extracts and cucumber.

Cons

  • Some customers reported allergic reactions despite the fact that the product is tested for allergy.
  • Cloths may dry out fast.

2. La Fresh Makeup Remover Cleansing Travel Wipes

La Fresh Makeup Remover Cleansing Travel Wipes

Specs:

  • Conditions the skin
  • Instantly dissolves waterproof makeup
  • Travel friendly

Makeup remover wipes are ideal for removing makeup on-the-go and convenient for travelling with. These La Fresh cleansing wipes contain vitamin E to condition and pamper the skin around your eyes after removing makeup. It will gently wipe off all makeup, including stubborn waterproof products without drying out your skin or causing any discomfort.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Comes in a pack of 50 individually wrapped wipes.
  • Contains vitamin E for skin care benefits.
  • Will not clog pores.

Cons

  • The wipes may lose their moisture if left unused over time.

3. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes -20 Individually Wrapped Wipes

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes -20 Individually Wrapped Wipes

Specs:

  • Alcohol Free
  • Ophthalmologist and Dermatologist Tested
  • Allergy Tested

These pre-moistened cleansing wipes are individually wrapped for moisture retention and freshness for a longer period of time. You can always throw a few in your gym bag or keep some in your hand bag for when you need to clean your face on the go. The wipes not only remove oil and dirt but every bit of waterproof makeup from your face, lips and eyes. Alcohol-free and gentle enough for sensitive skin and contact lens users.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Effective and gentle cleansing.
  • Pre-moistened and individually wrapped.
  • No need to rise after.

Cons

  • Priced higher than larger packs due to individual wraps.

4. Beauty by Earth Organic Makeup Remover

Beauty by Earth Organic Makeup Remover

Specs:

  • Cruelty Free
  • Not Tested On Animals
  • Organic Ingredients

This all natural makeup remover offers a chance to remove makeup in the most effective and gentle way without the use of any harsh chemicals or harmful ingredients. Suitable for all skin types, you can now give your skin the treatment it deserves and never worry about your makeup remover harming your skin. It also moisturizes and hydrates the skin leaving it fresh, clean and radiant.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Oil-free and non-drying.
  • Leaves zero residue on skin.
  • Suitable for all skin types.
  • Treats the skin.

Cons

  • May not be too effective in removing stubborn waterproof mascara.

5. La Fresh Makeup Remover Cleansing Travel Wipes -50 Individually Wrapped and Sealed

La Fresh Makeup Remover Cleansing Travel Wipes -50 Individually Wrapped and Sealed

Specs:

  • Biodegradable
  • Not tested on Animals
  • Airtight and Individually Wrapped

If you are looking for travel friendly makeup cleansing wipes that are compliant with Transportation Security Administration (TSA) rules then these are the wipes for you. Single and conveniently wrapped for moisture retention and easy travel, you can carry these in your gym bag, handbag or even in your pockets. The non-greasy cleansing formula removes makeup effortlessly while vitamin E helps to restore the skin’s natural and healthy condition. Made with 100% biodegradable materials your skin will be safe allergy or any sort of irritation.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Moisturizing Formula.
  • Contains vitamin E.
  • TSA-Approved.

Cons

  • According to some customers the wipes left a slight oily residue on the skin.
  • Not the most effective on waterproof makeup.

6. Eye Love Heyedrate Organic Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Eye Love Heyedrate Organic Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Specs:

  • Contains Tea Tree Oil and Vitamin E
  • No Chemicals or Harsh Ingredients
  • Safe for Sensitive Eyes

If you often find your eyes getting watery or red after makeup removal then maybe it is time to change your makeup remover. The Heyedrate Tea Tree Eye Makeup Remover contains only natural and organic ingredients to safely remove makeup from around the eyes without irritation the eye or the surrounding skin.  The oil based formula effectively wipes off all traces of makeup, including waterproof mascara, eye liner and shadows. Give your eyes the care and love they require even during makeup removal with this amazing 100% all natural product.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Removes contaminants and reduces inflammation.
  • Moisturizes the skin.
  • Easy to use.

Cons

  • The skin needs to be rinsed after the use of this product.
  • Could aggravate those already suffering from blepharitis.

7. The Face Shop Liquid Eye Makeup Remover

The Face Shop Liquid Eye Makeup Remover

Specs:

  • Made from Rice Water And Other Natural Ingredients
  • Enriched with Minerals
  • Mild Cleansing

If you want bright and younger looking skin after removing your makeup then check out this all natural makeup remover containing rice water, rejuvenating oils and antioxidants. There are no harmful substances in the ingredients so your skin will be free from irritation or any possible harm caused by harsh chemicals. Over time this gentle makeup remover promises to improve the appearance of the skin and give you a radiant glow.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Natural Brightening Solution.
  • Removes dead skin.
  • Ideal for removing waterproof makeup such as lipstick, mascara and eyeliner.

Cons

  • Not fragrance free.
  • Might leave a sheen on the skin after use.

8. We Love Eyes Tea Tree Eye Makeup Remover Oil

We Love Eyes Tea Tree Eye Makeup Remover Oil

Specs:

  • 100% All Natural Ingredients
  • 100% Cruelty Free
  • 100% Non Toxic

This all vegan makeup remover has been developed by Dr. Tania Gill whose main aim was to design a product that is free of all harmful chemicals and is 100% safe and healthy for the eyes. It is different from other regular makeup removers in the sense that it has been fashioned specifically for the eyes and the skin around the eyes. The unique formula is tough on make up yet gentle on the skin.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Ideal for waterproof mascara.
  • Safe for contact lens wearers.
  • Removes allergens.
  • Fragrance free.

Cons

  • Not recommended for people with eyelash extensions.
  • Requires the removal of contact lenses before use.

9. The Body Shop Camomile Waterproof Eye and Lip Makeup Remover

The Body Shop Camomile Waterproof Eye and Lip Makeup Remover

Specs:

  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Suitable for Contact Lens Wearers
  • Alcohol and Fragrance Free

Remove your waterproof eye and lip makeup with this gentle and soothing makeup remover by The Body Shop. If you spent the day wearing your long lasting mascara and lipstick or you partied the night away with multiple coats of waterproof makeup on your eyes and lips then have no worry because this product is designed to effectively take away every bit of your makeup without drying out your skin. It is free of paraben, gluten and alcohol so your skin will be feeling refreshed and new within seconds of using this remover.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • 100% Vegan.
  • Removes even the most stubborn waterproof mascaras and lipsticks.
  • Gentle formula.

Cons

  • Slightly oily.
  • The product had mixed reviews on its effectiveness on removing waterproof mascara. Some users said it didn’t wipe off waterproof mascara that easily or effectively..

10. Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Specs:

  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Paraben Free
  • Plant Derived Ingredients

Another amazing product by the well known brand Sephora, this waterproof makeup remover is designed to carefully remove traces of makeup from your eyes and leave the skin feeling soft and revitalized. The lash-strengthening formula is enriched with flavonoids and minerals such as olive wood extracts to condition your lashes and make them healthier.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Strengthens the lashes.
  • Suitable for contact lens wearers.
  • No synthetic fragrances.

Cons

  • Contents tend to evaporate quite quickly so need to keep the lid on.
  • Mixed reviews on effectiveness on removing waterproof mascara.

Things to Keep in Mind While Shopping For the Best Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Now that you have an idea of the best products on the market, you still need to be able to pick the most suitable one for your needs. Remember that not all waterproof eye makeup removers are designed the same so if you have any special requirements then you need to check for those earlier on.

Gentle Formula

People with sensitive eyes should opt for removers with natural ingredients to avoid irritation to the eyes. Your skin type also plays a role here so choose something with a safe and gentle formula.

Brands

It is always best to stick to well known brands that have earned a good reputation over the years and learn more about a product before purchasing it.

Effective

A quality waterproof makeup remover will not have you struggle to remove your makeup and should leave your skin feeling softer and smoother from before so you can look forward to going to bed with better skin.